Product Review: Page (1) of 2 - 09/06/06 Email this story to a friend. email article Print this page (Article printing at MyDmn.com).print page facebook
HP xw9400 Workstation: AMD Opteron vs. Intel Core 2 Extreme It's two against one as the Core 2 Extreme fights with one hand tied behind its back By Charlie White

HP today released its xw9400 Workstation (starting at $1999, $5999 as tested), a line of high-performance PCs incorporating next-generation 2000-series AMD Opteron processors. The company sent us a dual-processor dual-core workstation with two Opteron 2220SE processors running at 2.8GHz. Although the outside of the xw9400 looked a lot like its xw9300 predecessor we tested late last year, the inside was a different story. Running our suite of content creation benchmarks, we set out to evaluate the xw9400 and at the same time, see if two of these fastest Opteron processors could beat the speed of one Intel Core 2 Extreme (Conroe) processor.

The 9000 series from HP is intended for professionals such as digital content creators, oil and gas explorers, CAD engineers and such, and so maybe that's why the appearance of its the case is rather plain, a semi-retro rounded look that won't appeal to Apple fan boys but still has plenty of convenience inside for those who like to modify their PCs.

The chassis is completely tool-less, and its door comes off as easily as opening a refrigerator, reminding me of the latest Macs with their easy-open cases. The door on the xw9400 seems even heavier than its predecessor, and that's part of the sound-deadening technology employed by HP in this latest model. That, combined with ultra-quiet fans and the more-efficient Opteron 2220SE processors, makes this the quietest HP workstation we've tested so far. Sitting next to our previous champion of quietude, the Dell Precision Workstation 390 with an Intel Core 2 Extreme processor inside, the HP machine with its two processors was even quieter. HP techies tell me they've been working hard on quieting down these Opteron workstations, and their efforts have been a tremendous success. Bravo, HP.
Click image for enlargement

HP is covering the bases on both sides of the processor wars, where its 8000 series of workstations features Intel Xeon processors, and this 9000 series holds court with the AMD Opterons. HP offers a lot of great technology in the xw9400's computer case, and new for the 9400 are two PCI-Express x8 slots in addition to the two PCI-Express x16 slots of its predecessor. There's also the next-generation NVIDIA chipset onboard, this one including the nForce professional 3600 as well as 4GB of DDR-2 667MHz registered ECC RAM (you can fill it with 64GB if you so desire).  

Also on board is support for the latest and greatest SAS (Serial Attached SCSI) drives, two of which HP included in our test machine. The two 73GB 15000RPM drives, strapped together in a RAID-0 array, were nice and quiet while they nailed a head-turning 159MB/sec. read speed and a write speed of 163MB/sec. That's just a bit shy of the fastest SAS array we've seen here, but respectable, nonetheless. Also included in the configuration was a workstation-class graphics card, in this case the midrange NVIDIA Quadro FX3500 with 256MB of memory. Animators will want to boost that up a few notches, no doubt.

This is an excellent case design, with easy serviceability, great and quiet ventilation, and it even has decent onboard HD audio with the coaxial output in the back, but what about the speed? Can it even keep up with a single-processor Core 2 Extreme machine from Dell? In a word, yes. But it's not that simple. First of all, it doesn't seem to be a fair fight, with Intel's single dual-core processor going against two dual-core Opteron 2220SEs.

Page: 1 2 Next Page


Related Sites: Digital Producer ,   Media Workstation ,   Digital Video Editing ,   AEC Newsroom ,   Digital CAD ,   Animation Artist ,   Audio Video Producer ,   BN - Broadcast Newsroom ,   Digital Post Production ,   Film Imaging ,   HD Issues ,   Oceania ,   CEN - Desktops ,   IBN - IT Business Net ,   BN - NAB ,   BN - IBC ,   BN - Production ,   BN - Hardware
Related Newsletter: DMN Newsletter ,   Timeline Newsletter ,   Digital Media Net ,   BN - HD Weekly ,   DMNForums ,   Review Seeker ,   IBN - IT Weekly Newsletter
To Comment on This Article, Click HERE

Most Recent Reader Comments:
  • Re: HP xw9400 Workstation: AMD Opteron vs. Intel Core 2 Extreme by MikeMD at Sep. 10, 2006 1:15 am gmt (Rec'd 4)
  • Re: HP xw9400 Workstation: AMD Opteron vs. Intel Core 2 Extreme by mediajedi at Sep. 07, 2006 1:04 am gmt (Rec'd 4)
  • We have to compared it to a Mac Pro... by irisfailsafe at Sep. 07, 2006 9:06 pm gmt (Rec'd 4)
  • HP xw9400 Workstation: AMD Opteron vs. Intel Core 2 Extreme by DMN Editorial at Sep. 06, 2006 5:23 pm gmt (Rec'd 4)

    Click Here To Read All Posts
    Must be Registered to Respond (Free Registration!!!, CLICK HERE)

  • DMO TEXT LINKS
    (Click here to place a textlink on this site)

    Vegas Pro 8 + Free Vegas Seminar Series
    Master classes for cutting-edge video production
    A $100 value free with purchase
    CLICK HERE!!!

    Keep your camera rolling with Sony Mobile Storage for XDCAM EX Camcorders.
    Offload SxS memory cards onto 240GB HDD removable cartridges and accelerate your workflow on the go.
    Click Here!!!


    Adobe CS4
    Photoshop CS4 (Full Product, PC)
    By Adobe, start from $ 399.00
    Design Premium CS4 (Full Product, Mac)
    By Adobe, start from $ 648.18
    Master Collection CS4 (Full Product, PC)
    By Adobe, start from $ 1289.00
    Dreamweaver CS4 (Full Product, PC)
    By Adobe, start from $ 254.99
    Photoshop CS4 (Full Product, Mac)
    By Adobe, start from $ 385.99
    Production Premium CS4 (Full Product, PC)
    By Adobe, start from $ 697.88
    HOT THREADS on DMN Forums
    Content-type: text/html  Rss  Add to Google Reader or
Homepage    Add to My AOL  Add to Excite MIX  Subscribe in
NewsGator Online 
    Real-Time - what users are saying - Right Now!
        • Re: Reverse Mode in Vegas 9 • gspencer
    Dexim P-Flip Power Play Dock for iPhone/iPod touch
    polymer battery all in one neat device. Plug the P-Flip into your computer to charge its battery, then plug your iPhone into the P-Flip, and it charges the iPhone battery. Read More
    Apple Intros iPad
    After years of hype, Apple, Inc. today introduced the iPad, a portable computing device that looks like a big iPhone. Introduced today by Apple CEO Steve Jobs, the iPad features a touchscreen keypad, wireless capability, the capability to run all iPhone applications, all in a form factor that fits in between an iPhone and a MacBook. With the iPad, you can play movies, load maps, view photos, update your calendar, basically do the same things as on an iPhone, and more. Read More
    HDTV Buyer's Guidelines
    When it comes to choosing between Plasma and LCD, it's important to shop in the mindset that one high-def TV is not necessarily better than another - rather, it's a question of which one is right for you. That said, it can be a tough call to make when all that meets the eye are sleek screens and vibrant pictures - are Plasmas and LCDs really that different? Read More
    Tritton AX 180 universal gaming headset
    The Tritton AX 180 universal gaming headset is designed to work with the three major gaming platforms (Wii, xBox 360, and Sony PlayStation 3, via analog inputs), but also with both Macintosh and Windows based computers. Read More
    @ Copyright, 2010 Digital Media Online, All Rights Reserved